TCAS — collision avoidance system

2 contributors Last edited: Anonym Updated: 14. 6. 2026 Revision history

TCAS — airborne collision avoidance system

TCAS (Traffic Alert and Collision Avoidance System) is an onboard system that, independently of air traffic control, monitors surrounding aircraft and warns of an impending collision — and as a last resort gives the crew a direct command for a vertical manoeuvre. It is the last safety net in the air: it works even when ATC fails or when two crews do not realise they are on a collision course. Internationally the equivalent function is called ACAS II (Airborne Collision Avoidance System), and TCAS II is its specific, worldwide implementation. After several tragic mid-air collisions, TCAS became mandatory on all larger airliners and has saved countless lives.

TCAS — protection zones by time to collision outer zone → TA (advisory) inner → RA (manoeuvre command) ✈ ✈ What counts is the TIME to closest approach (tau), not just distance — higher up it decides earlier.
TCAS tracks the time to the closest point of approach (CPA). First it issues a TA (advisory), and if the collision threat persists, an RA (a command for a vertical manoeuvre).

How TCAS works

TCAS does not need ATC radar — it “sees" other aircraft by interrogating their transponders. It transmits an interrogation on 1030 MHz and the other transponder replies on 1090 MHz. From this, TCAS derives three things:

  • Range — from the time it takes for the reply to come back (like an echo).
  • Relative altitude — from the altitude reported in the reply (Mode C/S).
  • Bearing (azimuth) — using a directional antenna (approximately).

The key point is that TCAS works mainly with range and altitude; the bearing is less accurate, which is why the system resolves conflicts only in the vertical plane (climb/descend), never “turn left". The most modern is the Mode S transponder, which also allows direct data exchange between aircraft (see coordination below). An aircraft without a working transponder is invisible to TCAS — that is a fundamental limitation.

Tau and the closest point of approach (CPA)

TCAS does not decide on the basis of distance alone, but of time. It calculates the so-called tau — the approximate time to the CPA (Closest Point of Approach). When two aircraft are closing quickly, tau is small even at a large distance; when they pass slowly, the opposite. The tau thresholds also change with altitude (sensitivity levels, SL): higher up, the system warns earlier (there is more space and higher speeds), while low near the ground it is more cautious so as not to raise unnecessary alarms. This makes the protection appropriate to the phase of flight.

TA and RA — two stages

TCAS responds in two stages:

  • TA — Traffic Advisory: the call “Traffic, Traffic" alerts the crew to approaching traffic and where to look. A TA does not command a manoeuvre — it serves to gain awareness and prepare.
  • RA — Resolution Advisory: if the threat persists, TCAS issues a vertical command (e.g. “Climb, Climb" or “Descend, Descend"). An RA must be followed immediately and precisely.

The TA comes earlier (larger tau), the RA later and closer to the CPA. The aim is first to give the crew time to orient themselves, and only in the event of a real threat to command a manoeuvre.

TA: what to do and what not to do

When a “Traffic, Traffic" TA sounds, do not manoeuvre on it — a TA does not indicate the direction of resolution and a hasty manoeuvre can make things worse. The correct response: gain awareness (look outside and at the display), increase vigilance and prepare for a possible RA; if you see the traffic, you can agree an adjustment with ATC. The actual manoeuvre only comes with an RA. A TA thus means “get ready", an RA means “act".

Types of RA

RAs are not just “climb/descend". They are divided into:

  • Preventive: they require no change — e.g. “Monitor Vertical Speed" or “Maintain Vertical Speed"; they just keep you out of the danger zone.
  • Corrective: they require action — “Climb", “Descend" or “Level Off" (level out the vertical speed).
  • Crossing: the resolution goes through the other aircraft's level.
  • Increase: “Increase Climb/Descent" — when the original manoeuvre is not enough.
  • Reversal: “Climb NOW"/“Descend NOW" — TCAS reverses the original command, typically when the other aircraft is not responding correctly.

Once the conflict has passed, “Clear of Conflict" sounds and the crew returns to the previous altitude/clearance.

Coordinated RA via Mode S ✈ “CLIMB" ↑ ✈ “DESCEND" ↓ data exchange (Mode S) Two TCAS systems agree to issue opposite commands — one climbs, the other descends.
Two aircraft with TCAS II exchange commands via Mode S so that they avoid in opposite directions (one up, the other down) — never both in the same direction.

Coordination between aircraft

When both aircraft have TCAS II and a Mode S transponder, their systems agree via the datalink and select opposite, complementary commands — one gets “Climb", the other “Descend". This rules out the catastrophe of both heading in the same direction. If the other aircraft does not have TCAS (or has only a transponder), TCAS II assesses the situation on its own and chooses a safe manoeuvre. This coordination is the heart of the system — and its failure lay behind the best-known accident.

Several threats at once

TCAS can also handle a situation with several approaching aircraft at the same time — it selects a vertical manoeuvre that works against all the threats at once (e.g. a command that keeps separation above one aircraft and below another). If the geometry develops unfavourably, the command is increased (Increase) or reversed (reversal). The crew always follows only the current command — the system works out the complex geometry for them.

An RA takes priority over ATC — Überlingen

The most important rule is: in an RA you follow TCAS, even if ATC says the opposite. The reason was shown by the tragedy over Überlingen (1 July 2002): a Tu-154 (Bashkirian Airlines) and a Boeing 757 (DHL) were on a collision course. TCAS commanded the Tu-154 to climb, but the controller (overloaded, with incomplete systems) instructed it to descend. The crew obeyed ATC and descended — while the DHL aircraft was also descending according to its TCAS. The two aircraft collided and 71 people died. The investigation (BFU) clearly established: an RA takes priority over ATC instructions. Moreover, once an RA has been reported, ATC is temporarily not responsible for separation.

Automatic RA execution (AP/FD TCAS)

Modern aircraft (e.g. the Airbus A320 with the modification, the A350, A380) can execute an RA automatically — the autopilot itself performs the vertical avoidance (the AP/FD TCAS or “Auto-RA" function), and the crew only supervises and monitors. This reduces the risk of a wrong or late response. In older types the pilot must execute the RA manually (disconnect the autopilot and manoeuvre according to the command).

Responding to an RA — step by step

  1. Follow the command immediately (within ~5 s; even faster for a reversal RA). Don't think it over, don't check with ATC.
  2. If the autopilot is engaged and the aircraft has no Auto-RA, disconnect it and manoeuvre manually according to the command on the vertical speed indicator.
  3. Follow it precisely — no more, no less (the green “band" on the vertical speed indicator shows the target vertical speed).
  4. Report to ATC: “TCAS RA".
  5. After “Clear of Conflict", return to the assigned altitude and report it.

Inhibition of commands near the ground and at high altitude

TCAS adapts its commands to the phase of flight. Near the ground a descent would be more dangerous than the threat itself, so some RAs are inhibited: below roughly 1,100 ft above ground the “Descend" command is inhibited, below about 1,000 ft the system switches to TA only, and very close to the ground (around 500 ft) even the aural alerts fall silent — at that height the crew deals with the threat visually and according to procedures. Conversely, at very high levels, where the aircraft does not have the performance to climb steeply, the “Climb"/“Increase Climb" command may be inhibited. Thanks to these inhibitions, TCAS does not issue a manoeuvre that would itself endanger the aircraft (such as a descent just before landing).

Versions: TCAS I, II and the future

  • TCAS I — TAs (advisories) only, no commands; used on smaller aircraft.
  • TCAS II — TAs and RAs (vertical commands); the worldwide standard for airliners. The current logic is version 7.1.
  • v7.0 → v7.1: brought two safety fixes — the “Adjust Vertical Speed" command was replaced by the clearer “Level Off" (pilots sometimes reacted the wrong way) and the reversal logic was improved. Both fixes were a response to the Yaizu (2001) and Überlingen (2002) accidents, where the old logic did not reverse the command when one aircraft did not respond.
  • ACAS X — the upcoming successor with optimised logic and use of ADS-B; the aim is fewer unnecessary RAs and, in future, possibly horizontal resolution too.

Traffic display

Traffic is shown on the navigation display (ND) or a dedicated display and on the vertical speed indicator (IVSI/VSI):

  • White/cyan symbol — other or “proximate" traffic (no threat yet).
  • Solid yellow circle — TA (watch).
  • Red square — RA (manoeuvre).
  • Next to the symbol there is usually the relative altitude (±00 in hundreds of feet) and a climb/descent arrow.
  • On the vertical speed indicator a green band (target vertical speed) and a red band (prohibited values) light up.

Where TCAS is mandatory (Czech Republic → Europe → World)

The requirement comes from ICAO (ACAS II) and is implemented identically in the Czech Republic and the whole of Europe (EASA) and in the USA (FAA): TCAS II v7.1 is required on aircraft with a maximum take-off mass above 5,700 kg or with more than 19 passenger seats. Smaller aircraft usually have TCAS I or just a transponder. Operations in the Czech Republic follow the same rules as the rest of Europe.

Operating modes

  • STBY — standby (on the ground).
  • TA ONLY — advisories only, no commands (e.g. in the event of a failure, on closely spaced parallel runways).
  • TA/RA — the full mode (advisories and commands) in normal flight.

Nuisance RAs and how the system prevents them

For pilots to trust TCAS, RAs must be justified. Too many unnecessary (nuisance) RAs — say, for aircraft legally passing 1,000 ft below you — would lead crews to take them lightly. The v7.1 logic and the upcoming ACAS X therefore tune the thresholds so that they warn only of real risk and limit false alarms, especially in dense traffic and at parallel runways. This is also why the TA ONLY mode exists for situations where RAs would be counterproductive.

Limitations

  • Vertical resolution only — TCAS does not say “turn", only “climb/descend".
  • Requires a transponder — an aircraft without one (or with it switched off) is invisible.
  • Does not handle terrain — protection from the ground and obstacles is provided by another system (GPWS/TAWS).
  • The bearing is approximate — hence no reliance on lateral avoidance.
  • It does not replace lookout or ATC — it is an additional layer.
📷 Image placeholder: TCAS traffic display on the ND and the vertical speed indicator (TA in yellow, RA in red)
We will add a real photo / screenshot.

In practice — X-Plane / MSFS / DCS

  • In airliners (Zibo 737, FlyByWire A32NX, PMDG), set the transponder to TA/RA and in dense traffic (e.g. the VATSIM/IVAO online networks) watch the symbols and respond to RAs.
  • Practise responding to an RA: disconnect the AP (if it has no Auto-RA) and fly the vertical speed precisely according to the green band.
  • On the online networks, TCAS is excellent situational awareness training among real “pilots".
  • DCS: military aircraft do not have civil TCAS; radar/RWR and datalink (Link-16) play a remotely similar role, but the logic of a collision avoidance system is different — TCAS belongs to civil operations.

Related systems and history

TCAS works together with the transponder and increasingly with ADS-B (more precise position). Protection from terrain is provided by the separate GPWS/TAWS. TCAS was forced into being by mid-air collisions: Grand Canyon 1956 (TWA + United, 128 fatalities) accelerated the modernisation of ATC, and Cerritos 1986 (over Los Angeles) led to the TCAS and transponder mandate. TCAS is thus a textbook example of how safety systems are born from tragedies (see Air accidents).

Common mistakes

  • Obeying ATC instead of the RA — exactly what caused Überlingen; the RA always takes priority.
  • A late or “soft" response — an RA is followed immediately and precisely.
  • Manoeuvring against the RA (e.g. climbing on “Descend") — never.
  • Leaving the AP engaged in aircraft without Auto-RA.

FAQ

What is the difference between a TA and an RA? A TA is an advisory (watch the traffic), an RA is a command for a vertical manoeuvre (you must follow it).

Why doesn't TCAS say “turn"? It measures bearing only approximately; vertical resolution (climb/descend) is reliable.

Should I obey ATC or the RA? Always the RA — it takes priority; after an RA, ATC is relieved of responsibility for separation.

What did version 7.1 change? It introduced “Level Off" instead of “Adjust Vertical Speed" and improved the reversal logic (after Überlingen).

Does TCAS see an aircraft without a transponder? No — which is why the transponder is key and TCAS does not replace lookout.

Does the aircraft execute the RA by itself? Modern types do (AP/FD TCAS); older ones require a manual manoeuvre.

When is TCAS II mandatory? Above 5,700 kg MTOM or more than 19 passenger seats (ICAO/EASA/FAA).

Related links


Sources (verified 06/2026): ICAO Annex 10 Vol. IV (ACAS) and Doc 9863 (ACAS Manual), FAA “Introduction to TCAS II Version 7.1", SKYbrary (TCAS II v7.1, RA reversal), EUROCONTROL ACAS II Guide, BFU/NTSB (Überlingen 2002, Cerritos 1986, Grand Canyon 1956); the 1030/1090 MHz frequencies, the >5,700 kg/>19 pax requirement, types of RA, Mode S coordination, the v7.1 changes (CP115 Level Off + CP112E reversal logic) and ACAS X verified from multiple sources.