Air accidents — lessons for sim pilots

1 contributors Last edited: Anonym Updated: 14. 6. 2026 Revision history

Air accidents — lessons for sim pilots

Aviation is the safest form of transport precisely because it learns from accidents. Every tragedy leads to changes in regulations, technology and training. For a sim pilot: understanding the causes improves decision-making.

📷 Image placeholder: an accident investigation / safety illustration
We will add a real photo / screenshot.

Key accidents and lessons

  • Tenerife 1977 (583 fatalities, collision of two 747s on the runway) → standard phraseology, the birth of CRM.
  • Air France 447 (2009) — iced pitot tubes, loss of airspeed indication → training for unreliable airspeed and recovery from unusual attitudes.
  • Asiana 214 (2013) — low/slow on a visual approach → beware of automation dependency.
  • Boeing 737 MAX (Lion Air / Ethiopian, 2018–19) — the MCAS system → redesign of the system, training and certification.
  • Germanwings 9525 (2015) → the two-person cockpit rule.

The most common causes

  • Human factors (~70%) — communication, decision-making, situational awareness.
  • CFIT — controlled flight into terrain (countered by GPWS/TAWS).
  • Mechanical failure, weather (microburst, icing).

The chain of causes — the Swiss cheese model

A serious accident rarely arises from a single cause — it is usually a chain of small failures that unfortunately line up. This is explained by James Reason's famous Swiss cheese model: safety consists of layers of defence (procedures, technology, crew, ATC), each of which has “holes". An accident only happens when the holes in all the layers line up. The lesson for pilots and sim pilots: it is enough to break the chain at any point — and the accident will not happen.

Swiss cheese model: accident = passing through holes in the defences procedures technology crew ATC
Each layer has “holes". An accident only happens when they all line up at once.

Tenerife 1977 — communication

The deadliest accident in history (a collision of two Boeing 747s on the ground, 583 fatalities) showed how fatal unclear communication and a steep authority gradient in the cockpit can be — the captain took off without clearance and the junior crew did not speak up firmly enough. This and similar cases gave rise to CRM (see CRM). The lesson: standard phraseology and the courage to speak up save lives (see radiotelephony).

Eastern 401 (1972) — fixation of attention

An Eastern TriStar crashed into the Everglades because the entire crew was preoccupied with a burnt-out landing gear indicator bulb — and nobody was monitoring the aircraft. The autopilot disengaged unnoticed, the aircraft slowly descended and hit the swamp. The key lesson was: someone must always “fly the aircraft" (aviate, navigate, communicate). A minor fault is no reason to lose track of the fundamental thing — keeping the aircraft flying (see GPWS, which today prevents such an impact).

AF447 (2009) — loss of airspeed and stall

An Airbus A330 from Rio to Paris crashed into the Atlantic after ice blocked the pitot tubes and the airspeed indications became unreliable. The autopilot disconnected, the crew pulled up incorrectly, the aircraft entered a stall and fell from high altitude all the way to the sea — 228 fatalities. The lesson: master manual flying, recognise a stall and know the procedure for unreliable airspeed. In the simulator this is a great exercise — try flying without the automation.

📷 Image placeholder: an investigation team at the wreckage — working with the black boxes

US Airways 1549 (2009) — the Miracle on the Hudson

A positive example: shortly after takeoff from LaGuardia, an Airbus A320 struck a flock of geese, which knocked out both engines. Captain Sullenberger and the first officer assessed the situation within a few dozen seconds and ditched on the Hudson River — all 155 people survived. A showcase of excellent decision-making under pressure, training and CRM. The lesson: training and calm, quick decisions can handle even a “hopeless" situation (see bird strike).

Überlingen 2002 — follow the TCAS

Two aircraft collided over southern Germany because, faced with conflicting instructions, one crew followed the controller (descend) and the other the TCAS collision avoidance system (descend) — both descended. 71 fatalities. Since then there has been a clear rule: a TCAS instruction (RA) takes priority over an ATC instruction (see TCAS). The lesson shows how a tragedy becomes a globally binding rule that protects every flight today.

Boeing 737 MAX — automation and MCAS

Two Boeing 737 MAX accidents (2018 and 2019, 346 fatalities in total) were caused by the MCAS system, which, because of a single faulty angle-of-attack sensor, repeatedly pushed the nose down — and the crews had not been adequately informed about its behaviour. The type was grounded worldwide and redesigned. The lesson: automation must be understandable, must not depend on a single sensor, and the crew must know how to switch it off (see Boeing 737, autopilot).

How investigation improves safety

Every serious accident is followed by an independent investigation (in the Czech Republic by the ÚZPLN, in France the BEA, in the USA the NTSB, in Germany the BFU) under ICAO Annex 13. Its sole aim is prevention, not apportioning blame — which is why a just culture is applied, in which people are not afraid to admit mistakes. Analysis of the black boxes (see black box) produces safety recommendations that change regulations, technology and training. Each accident thus advances the safety of the whole system.

Why flying is safe

Despite the media attention, air travel is one of the safest ways to travel — precisely thanks to decades of lessons from accidents. The system is built on layers of defence, standard procedures, redundancy and continuous improvement. For a sim pilot, studying accidents is valuable: you understand why rules and checklists exist and what happens when they are bypassed. We learn safely from the mistakes of others — and in the simulator we can safely try out situations you would never want to experience in reality.

CFIT — controlled flight into terrain

A special and insidious category is CFIT (Controlled Flight Into Terrain) — when a fully functioning aircraft hits the ground, water or an obstacle because the crew lost awareness of their position or altitude (often at night, in cloud or when disoriented). It is not a failure but a loss of situational awareness. It was precisely to counter CFIT that the GPWS/TAWS systems were created (see GPWS), which warn the crew loudly (“PULL UP"). The lesson: always know the minimum safe altitudes and take system warnings deadly seriously — many CFIT accidents ended tragically only because a warning was underestimated.

Practical steps — simulator

Replay famous accidents as scenarios (unreliable airspeed, a microburst on final, CFIT in the mountains) and practise the correct response. In DCS/airliners, debrief your own flights (Tacview, replay).

FAQ

Is flying dangerous? On the contrary — statistically very safe, thanks to the culture of learning from mistakes.

What is the “Swiss cheese model"? An accident happens when the “holes" in several layers of protection line up.

Related links


Sources (verified 06/2026): official reports (NTSB, BEA, AAIB), SKYbrary; Tenerife 1977 = 583 fatalities (the deadliest accident in aviation). An educational summary; for details, see the official investigation reports.